Cardinal, panelists: Pope’s celebrity should turn eyes to Jesus

March 19, 2014
 
By Maria Wiering

mwiering@CatholicReview.org
 
“Like Pope Francis? You’ll love Jesus.”

It was a well-circulated Washington Post headline in December, but it could have been the tagline for the March 18 Francis Factor event held at Loyola University Maryland in Baltimore. As a cardinal, archbishop and four Catholic expert panelists shared insights from Pope Francis’ first year, they repeatedly shifted the attention away from the pope and onto the Son of God.

Pope Francis would have done no less.

“The pope is a true companion of Jesus,” said Cardinal Seán P. O’Malley, a Capuchin Franciscan and archbishop of Boston, in the evening’s keynote address. Speaking to an audience of some 2,800 in Loyola’s Reitz Arena, Cardinal O’Malley said the pope is enticing people to take a new look at the church.

In a famous interview published in English by America magazine in September, the pope called the church “a field hospital after battle.”

“The field hospital imagery is more compelling than that of a museum or a concert hall,” the cardinal said. “Sometimes we lose our enthusiasm for mission because we forget that the Gospel responds to our deepest needs, since we were created for what the Gospel offers us: friendship with Jesus and love of our brothers and sisters.”

The Francis Factor was hosted by the Archdiocese of Baltimore, part of its 225th anniversary celebration. The evening included an introduction from Baltimore Archbishop William E. Lori, the address from Cardinal O’Malley, and by remarks followed by a question-and-answer session from four panelists: Basilian Father Thomas Rosica, founding chief executive officer of the Canadian Catholic network Salt and Light Television; Jesuit Father Matt Malone, editor-in-chief of America magazine; Helen Alvaré, professor of law at George Mason University School of Law in Arlington, Va., and a consultor for the Pontifical Council of the Laity; and Kerry Robinson, executive director of the National Leadership Roundtable on Church Management.

Baltimore’s Catholic Charities, Catholic Review Media and the Catholic Community Foundation of the Archdiocese of Baltimore also supported the two-hour event.

To view a slideshow from the event, navigate the arrows below.
See a photo you like? View the Catholic Review Smugmug gallery for purchasing options.

Ignatius and Francis

Wearing his brown Franciscan habit, Cardinal O’Malley framed his remarks with the connection between St. Ignatius of Loyola and St. Francis of Assisi. Ignatius read about St. Francis, and the friar’s example of self-denial and heroism played an important role in Ignatius’ conversion and founding of the Jesuit order.

Pope Francis can be understood not as a Jesuit who leans Franciscan, but as a fully Ignatian Jesuit, Cardinal O’Malley said.

He pointed to the pope washing the feet of young people, including young women, in a detention center on Holy Thursday. Catholics used to experiencing a stylized feet-washing ritual were surprised to see the pope in such a humble role before the youths.

“Pope Francis replicated the surprise and the shock of the apostles, even as he dismayed those who prefer the stylized liturgy in a basilica,” said Cardinal O’Malley, a member of the Council of Cardinals, which advises the pope on major initiatives. “The Holy Father was jostling our imagination because we’ve grown so complacent that we can no longer see beyond the familiar customs to glimpse a challenging truth.”

Like Pope Benedict XVI before him, Pope Francis says Catholicism is not a catalog of prohibitions, the cardinal said.

“He urges us to be positive, to focus on the things that unite us, not the negative, the things that divide us. You must prioritize the connection between people, the path we walk together. After that, addressing the differences becomes easier,” Cardinal O’Malley said. “Every form of catechesis should attend to the way of beauty.”

All of the evening’s speakers expounded on Pope Francis’ love for the poor and his call for mercy.

Father Malone said some Catholics run the risk of “being religious, but not spiritual” and viewing truth as an idea, not the person Jesus.

“The Holy Father isn’t saying that the rules are wrong, only that they’re not the essence of our faith. Relationship is the essence of our faith,” he said. “The rules only exist to safeguard relationships. The Catechism of the Church expresses the tradition of the church and its pilgrim journey to the fullness of life and love. In other words, it is not a penal code.”
 
A ‘Marian church’

Alvaré focused on Pope Francis’ call for women to assume a greater presence in the church. For a blueprint of how that might look, she said, one only has to look to Pope Francis. His relational and familial approaches reflect “women’s capacity to put other people at the center of the universe,” she said.

“It is the Marian face of the church, and the world’s over-the-top reaction to it is a striking indication of the need for it,” she said.

She cautioned that there might be a temptation within the church to admire and value the contributions of women in theory, but not in fact.

“It will take more than goodwill to grasp and promote a Marian church and the gifts that women provide in it and for it,” she said. “One needs women not only on the front lines, but in the back office and also the executive suite. Obviously, not in the spirit of careerism, but in the same spirit of servant leadership that Pope Francis is inviting.”

Robinson also spoke of Pope Francis’ call for women’s leadership, which should arise “not for the sake of women, but for the sake of the church.” She said Catholics would benefit from reflecting on the role of St. Clare, who formed a women’s religious community to participate in St. Francis’ work.
 
Rebuilding church

Father Rosica said it is possible for people to get hung up on the externals of Pope Francis’ ministry – driving a Ford Focus, wearing simpler garments, making a jam sandwich for a member of the Swiss Guard protecting his apartment – and miss the heart of the message.

“While I have loved St. Francis of Assisi … Francis of Buenos Aires does not transport me back to medieval Assisi, and not even Loyola,” he said. “He’s taking us back to Bethlehem, to Galilee, to Jerusalem. Everything he’s doing now is not just imitation of his patron saint … it’s a reflection of someone else: the child of Bethlehem who would grow up to become a man of the cross.”

He added: “Francis is giving the world a very powerful glimpse into the heart and the mind of God.”

He pointed to the message that St. Francis received from God: “Rebuild my church.” At first, St. Francis took it literally, but later understood it figuratively, as a calling to serve others, especially the poor. Pope Francis is doing the same thing today, Father Rosica said.

“The most important ‘Francis factor’ is the invitation to all of us to be Christ-like in the way that he is and collectively encounter the poor, not just be aware of the poor or work on behalf of the poor … and thus be transformed ourselves,” Robinson said.
 
Same church, new look

The most important achievement of Pope Francis’ first year, which celebrated its anniversary March 13, is that he has “re-branded Catholicism and the papacy,” Father Rosica said.

Such seemed to be the case for an audience member, who addressed the panel during the evening’s question-and-answer session. A Loyola student who implied he is gay said he was raised Catholic but felt pushed out of the church. Pope Francis made him feel like he might have a place in the church again.

“My concern is that words can only go so far,” he said. “Without actual change in doctrine or Canon law, how will that filter down to the bishops and the priests that actually impact people’s lives?”

Father Malone confirmed that Pope Francis does not intend to change the church’s doctrine, but said not to discount the power of his shift in tone.

“Certainly since the Second Vatican Council, the church has taught, among other things about human sexuality, that gay and lesbian people ought to be accepted with compassion, sensitivity and respect,” he said. “What this pope has done, which I think is so important, is that he has said that is not only a part of the church’s teaching, that is the most important part of the church’s teaching about gays.”

Instead of tacking on that teaching to conversations about human sexuality, Catholics should lead with it, Father Malone said.

“If we are to envision a church in which everyone is welcome, we have to start there,” he said.

Other questions were submitted online and involved evangelization, church finance responsibility, and economic policy. One questioner asked how to channel the pope’s celebrity into Catholic action.

“The way that the church grows is by the witness of the Gospel,” Cardinal O’Malley said. “The response has to be personal conversion and transformation.”

Archbishop Lori said that Pope Francis has opened many hearts to the beauty of the Christian life, “and has won a fresh hearing for the Gospel the world over.”

“He quite simply walks the walk,” he said.

See also: